Friday, September 19, 2008

House of Bishops begins special session in Salt Lake City with Lambeth review

As the House of Bishops of the Episcopal Church meets this week in Salt Lake City, Utah, a team of bishops will report each day on the proceedings, which are closed to press and public. The first report, filed on September 17, follows.
The Bishops of the Episcopal Church gathered in Salt Lake City, Utah, for a special session of the meeting of the House of Bishops.
 
Present were 128 bishops. Not present were 15 who could not attend for a variety of reasons, including the bishops of Texas who are dealing with the aftermath of Hurricane Ike. Nine did not respond and were not present.
 
Following morning worship, the bishops met in small table groups to debrief the recent Lambeth Conference.  The bishops were presented with two questions for discussion: "What were we most grateful for; and what were we least grateful for?" The afternoon plenary focused on what lies ahead.
 
Bishops consistently expressed gratitude for the relationships developed during Bible Study, Indaba groups and informal conversations throughout the Lambeth Conference.  Many reported that these relationships are continuing through email contact, and the establishment of companion relationships between dioceses around the world.  The bishops expressed gratitude for the Archbishop of Canterbury's leadership, especially during the retreat.  Many expressed appreciation for the expansion of the world view they received.
 
Concerns expressed included the disjunction between the Lambeth Indaba Process and future decision-making. Many compared the deep and collegial conversation of the Indaba Process with the more contentious hearings held by the Windsor Continuation Group and the Covenant Design Group. 
 
In the afternoon plenary, there was lively discussion as we looked forward to extending the Lambeth Conference experience. A wide range of topics was presented including: a cooperation on the environment; global warming; poverty reduction; and improved communication throughout the Communion. HOB also discussed inviting Primates and bishops to visit The Episcopal Church. In turn, some bishops expressed a desire to visit other parts of the Communion. Throughout the day, gratitude was expressed for existing and developing relationships, and their significant value to our mutual life in the Anglican Communion.
 
Prepared by:
Bishop Thomas Breidenthal of Southern Ohio
Bishop Mary Gray-Reeves of El Camino Real
Bishop Gordon Scruton of Western Massachusetts
Bishop Geralyn Wolf of Rhode Island

Monday, September 8, 2008

Dialogue, compromise highlight Communion’s Lambeth Conference

The Lambeth Conference brought together bishops, spouses, priests and ecumenical partners. Participants, including the Anglican Church of Canada’s Canon Alyson Barnett-Cowan (foreground) walk through Canterbury on the way to opening worship. marites n. sison



Nearly every Lambeth Conference has had a hot button issue. In 1948, bishops were divided over what to do with the bishop of Hong Kong's decision two years earlier to ordain the first woman priest, Florence Li Tim Oi. In 1998, they were divided anew over women bishops. Yet, these and other conferences were able to ride out these storms and tensions, and Anglicanism survived. This year was no exception.

"Is this the end of the Anglican Communion?" a newspaper headline read at the start of this year's conference held July 16 to Aug.3 in Canterbury, England. After all, more than 250, or one out of four, bishops decided to boycott it to protest the presence of pro-gay bishops.

But the Conference has proven that, despite being deeply divided over the consecration of an American gay bishop and the blessing of same-sex unions in a Canadian diocese, "There is no desire to separate." Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams quoted what most of the 670 bishops who attended the conference had told him. The retreat at the historic Canterbury Cathedral, daily Bible study sessions, and the introduction of indaba, adopted from an African method of addressing village issues, appears to have worked.

The problems did not disappear and there were no illusions that it would. But the desire to remain at the table and to reach out to those who chose not to show up is strong, the bishops said in the Reflections document released on the conference's last day.

Although the controversial issue of human sexuality dominated the discussions and headlines worldwide, the bishops did many other important things. They marched through the streets of central London to urge world governments to live up to their promise to halve global poverty by 2015. They joined their spouses in looking at the abuse of power and violence against women. They engaged with and listened to leaders from other faith communities present as participants. They discussed how Anglicans can help address issues related to the environment, peace, and justice.

The bishops' spouses worked equally hard – they looked at and tried to equip themselves in their roles as wives/husbands and, in most cases, as partners in ministry. On the side, they also got to have a bit of fun – tea with the Queen, and excursions through the British countryside.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

NH's Bishop Robinson tells of support, resistance at Lambeth

For Trinity Episcopal Church, it was a routine visitation by Bishop Gene Robinson, complete with a liturgical service and coffee in the basement. For Robinson, it was a welcome return home after a major conference for bishops in England where he received both support and resistance.

On Tuesday, Robinson conducted a visitation of Trinity Episcopal Church in Meredith, including officiating a confirmation and reception service for five local people, including four youths.

Robinson recently returned from the Lambeth Conference in Canterbury, England, an assembly of Anglican bishops that takes place once every 10 years. While he did not attend the conference itself, he enjoyed his time there.

"I think [the trip] accomplished what it set out to do, which was to build relationships." he said, listening to such talks as the "Bishop of Harare tell about what it is like in Zimbabwe. Just the chance to hear what that's like is just amazing."

The presence of Robinson, the church's first openly gay bishop, at the conference was itself the result of struggle and determination. He was not formally invited to this year's conference by the Archbishop of Canterbury, the head of the Anglican Church, though he still attended.

Robinson said he received both resistance and support while in Canterbury. Sentiments included anxiety and concerns he would protest to receiving words of support from a large group of youths

In his sermon, he recalled being told by a reporter, "You seem like the least stressed person here," to which he replied, "You may be right."

"I think that when you act as if you know God's love for you, people notice," Robinson said

In the end, Robinson is happy serving in the churches and with his parishioners in New Hampshire.

"I'm just home, thank you Jesus," Robinson said during the service. "I almost kissed the tarmac when I arrived in Manchester."

At Tuesday's service he preached on the importance of recognizing one's spiritual vocation in everyday life and work. He was also given a pair of purple socks by the Rev. Robin Thomas Soller of Trinity in thanks for his presence.

At the end of the service, he joined parishioners for coffee and conversation in the church basement, having his photo taken with a few parishioners and signing a copy of his book "In the Eye of the Storm."

"This is the favorite part of what I do, being in the basement, eating food that everyone has prepared," he said. "This is where it happens and I'm so pleased to be back to being where I'm just the bishop."

His overall reception in the state has been supportive and positive.

"People are saying, 'We are so glad you're back,'" Robinson said. "Almost everybody says, 'We're so glad you are safe.' It's amazing, and I love these people and for some odd reason they seem to like me."
NH's Bishop Robinson tells of support, resistance at Lambeth
The Citizen, United States

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Lambeth exceeded expectations, says Williams

The Archbishop of Canterbury yesterday hailed the recent Lambeth conference as a success while at the same time acknowledging the difficulties that lie ahead for the Anglican Communion.

In a 1,500-word pastoral letter, sent by post over the bank holiday weekend to the 650 bishops who were in Canterbury last month for the once-a-decade meeting, the Right Rev Rowan Williams set out his personal reflections on the 17-day summit.

He wrote that Lambeth had succeeded "to a remarkable degree, more than most people expected" in allowing all of the bishops to be heard. There was no doubt that nearly all those attending wanted the Communion to stay together.

The conference, Lambeth 2008, was designed to maintain unity in the face of global rifts over the ordination of gay bishops, blessings of same-sex unions and cross-border interventions.

About 230 bishops, mostly from Uganda, Nigeria and Kenya, boycotted the event. Many of these absentees were at the launch of a breakaway movement, the Global Anglican Future Conference, which is aimed at traditionalists.

Williams also had to deal with discontent at home over the decision to ordain women as bishops with no special measures for objectors, and he arrived in Canterbury bruised by a divisive meeting of the general synod.

Williams uses the letter to illustrate the Communion's common goals. It also reiterates the official position on homosexuality - which is that it is incompatible with Scripture - and notes that "premature" or "unilateral" local change is "risky and divisive".


Lambeth exceeded expectations, says Williams
guardian.co.uk, UK

Thursday, August 21, 2008

No surprise here: UGANDA'S Anglican leaders support president's speech demonizing homosexuality

[Ecumenical News International, Nairobi] Some Ugandan Anglican church leaders have expressed support for a statement by President Yoweri Museveni in which he commended the denomination's bishops for resisting homosexuality.

"It was great of the president to speak about the issue," Anglican Bishop Stanley Ntagali of Masindi–Katara told Ecumenical News International on August 20. "We have been inspired by the president's positive comments."

Uganda's New Vision newspaper on August 17 quoted Museveni as saying he saluted the bishops of Africa for resisting "disorientation" and a "decadent culture." The newspaper said the bishop had made his remarks when he spoke at the consecration of the Rev. Canon Patrick Gidudu as the Anglican bishop of Mbale in eastern Uganda. During his address, Museveni said homosexuality was a result of "Western influence."

"Don't fear; resist and do not compromise on that. It is a danger not only to the believers but to the whole of Africa. It is bad if our children become complacent and think that people who are not in order are alright," Museveni was quoted as saying.

This is the first time an African national leader has spoken out in the recent Anglican debate over homosexuality.

"When he speaks in this manner to the bishops, it will energise the resolve against homosexuality," said the secretary of Uganda's Anglican church, the Rev. Aaron Mwesigye, in an interview with ENI. "The Uganda church has been very bold against homosexuality."

Ugandan Anglican Archbishop Henry Luke Orombi presided over the Mbale consecration. Orombi had boycotted the once-every-decade Lambeth Conference of bishops from the Anglican Communion in July 2008, along with the primates of Anglican churches in Nigeria, Rwanda and Kenya, due to differences over homosexuality within the communion.

"The Anglican church is facing significant challenges but I would like to assure you that the church is steady," Orombi told his congregation.

Sunday, August 17, 2008

Anglican bishops @ Lambeth conference had opportunity to see play about gay Christians

GRAND RAPIDS, Michigan: An acting troupe performed a play about gay Christians for the world's Anglican bishops gathering earlier this month in Canterbury, England.

The play, "Seven Passages," critically examines Bible verses about homosexuality.

The Western Michigan University ensemble's  performances coincided with the bishops' discussions of sexuality, an issue that has splintered the 77 million-member Anglican Communion.

This year's conference is the first since the 2003 consecration of the only openly gay Episcopal bishop, the Rt. Rev. V. Gene Robinson of New Hampshire. The Episcopal Church is the Anglican body in the U.S.


See Anglican bishops attending conference will have opportunity to see ...
International Herald Tribun

Friday, August 15, 2008

Lambeth Reflections of Bishop Marc Andrus

Lambeth Reflections

The Lambeth Conference came to its conclusion today, Sunday. I would like to thank the courageous –"acting from the heart" – people who came to Canterbury from many places to tell their stories as lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgendered people, as part of the Listening Process called for by Lambeth '98, the Windsor Document, the Primates, and the Archbishop of Canterbury. As I pointed out in several settings at the conference, the strength and courage of LGBT people coming to a place where it was commonly heard that there were significant negative places of negative energy aimed at them is something to honor.

Tom Jackson, the president of Oasis California was an on-the-ground, tireless, manager and encourager for all present. Those telling their stories included: the Rev. Vicki Gray, deacon in the Diocese of California, Tom Poynor, chaplain at the UC Berkeley,  Rowan Smith, Dean of St. George's Cathedral, Cape Town, South Arica. Cynthia Black, Louise Brooks, and Katie Sherrod produced a powerful documentary of LGBT people telling their stories in Africa that had two showings at Lambeth. Mimi Walters journey from Baltimore, and lesbian and gay clergy came from the Diocese of North Carolina.  The Rev. Fr. Michael Lapsley, of Institute for Healing of Memories spoke on reconciliation.

While there were barriers to hearing these grace-filled, transformative stories, still the connections were made. The contributions the above people made to the Lambeth Conference are akin to the dynamism Jesus talked about in his parable about a mustard seed – small, seemingly insignficant, but in the end generous and unmistakable.

Relations
The document that came out of the Lambeth Conference, the final draft of which we saw at the last plenary session yesterday, is a distillation of the Indaba Group conversations that have gone on over the length of the conference. All of us were assigned to Bible study groups that met each morning. Five Bible study groups constituted an Indaba Group, which met after the individual study groups.

What has emerged from the extended time in the Bible study and Indaba Groups is relationship. Bishops spoke honestly and deeply. We found places of profound commonality, and we named honestly pain in division that was not erased.

One Sudanese bishop said this, "After 22 years of suffering (civil war) we have learned not to run away based on what we hear, but to come and see, and then decide rather we need to run away. We are not leaving these friendships."

There was much talk about "What I need to take back to my diocese." People asked me that quite a lot. Was it moratoria on blessings, on incursions? Was it commitment to the relief of global suffering through the Millennium Development Goals process? An Anglican Covenant?

For me it is the relationships. Unlike most of the other products, the usefulness of the relationships formed at the Lambeth Conference will lie in the extension of the relationships into our diocese, and beyond. As I wrote in an earlier posting, part of the way bishops must now fulfill their ministry of unity is by actively extending the relationships they have to others, and even understanding that these relationships need to develop apart from the bishops themselves. I am coming home to the beautiful Diocese of California knowing that there are great opportunities for becoming a global body that contributes to the healing of the world, and that people in the Bay Area are eager to be part of this. The same Sudanese bishop who spoke so movingly of his province's brave journey to Lambeth (when significant neighbor provinces stayed away based on what they had "heard") has asked me whether people in California could help his people with the HIV/AIDS pandemic in Sudan. Who better than we?

Products
As to the other 'products' I mentioned above: the document we produced has real significance as it reflects the searching, prayerful conversations over a two week period of over 600 Anglican bishops. The points of substantial agreement are thus worth our attention. In California we will be seeking ways to utilize the indaba process to consider the contents of the document, absorb and extend its learnings, and contribute back to the whole.

At the same time, the document is not legislation. We will pay close attention to it, but we must not reify the agreement points in it into laws, and we should resist interpretations that seek to employ those agreements as laws.

Some of those places of broad agreement are:
Moratoria. There was widespread agreement that moratoria are needed in the areas of: same-sex blessings, consecrations to the episcopate of partnered gays or lesbians, and incursions by one province or diocese into the ecclesial life of another province or diocese.

Archbishop Rowan in his final presidential address, given just after we received the reflections document noted that, "There will be some who cannot abide by these moratoria, and in this they signal that there are steps to deeper unity they cannot take; or it may be that they conceive of deeper unity in other ways."  I take this to be a profound and generous idea. In not abiding by the moratorium on same-sex blessings I take it as incumbent on me and on us in the Diocese to actively labor to both understand the position of those to whom that moratorium is important, and to convey the reality of our life together to the world. I must redouble my efforts at inhabiting a deeper unity.

Millennium Development Goals. Following up on the Walk of Witness in London, there will be a Communion-wide day of vigil, prayer, and fasting on September 25, while the United Nations is meeting in New York. The Episcopal Church will have a presence there, along with representatives of provinces and dioceses throughout the Communion. All of this is to highlight the need to recommit to the MDGs in order to halve extreme poverty by 2015.

This Communion-wide act of witness and advocacy is something towards which I have been working and praying for six years. I believe it is also the fruit of much of Archbishop Rowan's ministry, the result of his ministry as Archbishop of Canterbury – combining faith and action at a global level. The global church, he said, is not just existent to manage internal conflict, but to aid in the healing of the world's wounds.  Interdependent churches, globally connected, praying and worshipping as the base of their work of healing in the world, in this consists the catholic faith.

We must see September 25 as a starting point, not as an end point. The Diocese of California has been laboring to understand and implement the Millennium Development Goals in our common life. We may view this Lambeth agreement as an opening for greater partnerships and possibilities, an answer to prayer.

Environment. Environmental sustainability is Goal 7 of the MDGs. The environmental crisis, however, was of such deep concern to the bishops gathered at Lambeth 2008 that it was given attention as a separate but related subject area in the final document. In our Indaba Group I heard bishops speak with passion and intimate knowledge of sustained droughts in Australia, degradation from wide-scale and unchecked mining in India, damn building, the pollution of the oceans, and environmental effects of globalization and "affluenza." The window of opportunity to reverse the negative effects of climate change is closing far more rapidly than even our scientific community thought twenty years ago. One bishop quoted projections he read just before the conference began that said we have about 100 months to do the emergency work we must do.

In the Diocese of California I am heartened by the revitalized work of the Environmental Commission, and the network of liaisons to the Commission that has been formed, but am aware that at the present we exist more as potential energy than as an active network. We must and will respond to this crisis with intelligence, commitment, and will. It is essential that we not only move into greater action, but that we also see that action as prayer, that we root our action in prayer and theology. It is also essential that we link our diocesan efforts with others in Province Eight of The Episcopal Church.

An Anglican Covenant. In an address he gave during the Lambeth Conference, Archbishop Rowan said that a covenant for the Communion, "should help us grow together." While there is widespread will for an Anglican Covenant expressed in the final document of Lambeth 2008, there was equally widespread opposition to the sections (3 and the Appendix) of the St. Andrew's Draft Covenant that make the proposed covenant an instrument of dis-union rather than its hoped for opposite. I think we will have a covenant at some time in the future, and I think it will be a much different thing than what we have seen yet, all of which has been born out of fear and anxiety.

Bishop Steven and I have been encouraging a group of non-Episcopal Church, non- Church of England bishops, clergy and laity to form to present some lively alternative ideas for the design  group, contributions that may influence what goes to the Anglican Consultative Council in late Spring of next year. There are interesting ways of creating community, and healing community that have little to do with Western legal and legislative systems, and it might be good to hear about such processes.

Partners. Finally, I want to say what a pleasure it was to work with and spend time with Bishop Steven Charleston during the Conference. We met every day over breakfast, a touchstone of real use to me as the intense days were beginning. I am so hopeful about all of our work together in the future of the Diocese of California, and Bishop Steven is joining a great ministering community at Diocesan House, and bringing his own great heart and intelligence to that lovely partnership that serves the diocese.

Bishop Steven and I also hosted an evening with the Province of Brazil, including Bishop Naudal and Carmen from the Diocese of Curitiba, our Companion Diocese. After the fun dinner, I excused myself to go to another room in the same building to host the second screening of Voices of Witness from Africa. I looked up to see all the bishops and spouses of the Province of Brazil joining us there. I think this says a great deal about our brothers and sisters in Brazil, and about the good work and life we are going to share.